HISTORY OF 1766 COLUMBIA AVE
"On 27 May 1717, Isaac Kaufmann (in English,
Coffman) received a warrant for 300 acres in what became the
northeast corner of Manor township, Lancaster county, PA. It was
surveyed on 14 October 1717, and the patent finally issued on 11
November 1734. Among his close neighbors were David Herr (patent 3
June 1761), Hans Snider (warrant 26 November 1717), and John
Bumgarner (apparently not of our Bumgarners) (surveyed 22 October
1736). Jacob Coffman received a plot nearby in 1733, and John
Coffman in 1743. These were likely sons or brothers of Isaac. The
northern boundary of the original Kaufmann grant is now the boundary
between Manor and East Hempfield townships (and also Columbia Ave.),
the east boundary that between Manor and Lancaster townships.
Improvements to the property
included a house built in 1767 and another house built in 1785. In
1793, 180 1/2 acres of this property were purchased by Christian
Stoner, who sold it to William Gamber about 8 years later. In 1807
William added a major barn to the property. A stone plaque rescued
after the barn burnt about 1965 says "Erbauet durch William Gamber
und Anna Gamber im Jahr 1807". Another plaque says "Rebuilt by
Rudolph Gamber and Mary his wife Mary 16, 1853". (These stones are
now in the root cellar of the 1767 house.)
In 1858, Henry S Gamber, probably
the son of John Gamber born 1801 (exact relationship not yet
determined, but possibly the second son of William) purchased from
an heir of Isaac Kaufmann an adjacent plot of land on which he built
a house. This building, with some additions, is now the Tobias S
Frogg restaurant and bar on Columbia Ave (state road 462). A stone
in the wall says "Built by Henry S Gamber AD 1858".
After the death of William in
1863, the property passed to his oldest son Rudolph. At the time,
Rudolph was living in the 1767 house, William and his second wife in
the 1785 house. William's grave marker reads "William Gamber, born
Sept. 23rd, 1771, died Sept. 7th, 1863, aged 92 years 11 months and
11 days" (sic} The marker of his first wife Anna reads "Anna, wife
of William Gamber, born July 1st, 1779, died Mar 4th, 1861, aged 82
years, {broken off} months, 1 day" (sic).
After the death of Rudolph in
1873 the house passed to his son John Landis Gamber. On his death in
1887 it passed to his son John Herr Gamber. John Herr had no
children and on his death in 1955 the property passed to his nephew
Ben Stauffer - son of John H's oldest sister Alice Herr Gamber who
had married Benjamin Shenk Stauffer. Ben Stauffer divided the
property, and in 1960 sold a part with the 1767 house (since
enlarged, and with the address 155 Gamber Lane) to J L Dickerman.
The 1785 house (now with the address 135 Gamber Lane) was purchased
by James L Corrigan. Later when a development of the remaining farm
property was proposed, Corrigan and Dickerman purchased the lane and
some additional property for a total of about 6 acres. J L's son
Steve lives on the lane also, in the house at the north end. This
land is a green oasis adjoining the type of gray (literally) high
density "suburban" development now so common around the US.
The farm had included a graveyard
for the Kaufmann, Gamber and Stauffer families. The developer
bulldozed that area. Dickerman saved several of the grave markers,
which are now in the root cellar of his house.
To reach the farm, from Columbia
Ave (SR 462), turn south on S Yale St (Hess gas station at corner),
then right at the first corner (just past fire station) onto Temple,
left at the first street Gamber Lane. The Tobias Frogg is 3 block
further west on Columbia."
That information comes from the wesite www.gamber.net/gamber/farm-lan/index1.html.
The building has housed four
different restaurants during it's lifetime. The first, and
most well known was the Lemon Tree. The Lemon Tree was open
for many years, and was one of Lancaster's best fine dining
establishments. Next came D J's Hideaway. When D J's
closed, Treo's opened up for a short time. After that, 1766
Columbia Ave sat empty untill Jeff and Beth Conklin along with
parteners Sandy and Dennis Herr opened up Tobias S. Frogg in
1993. Jeff and Beth bought out Sandy and Dennis and continue
to own and operate the Frogg today.
Tobias S. Frogg has had it's
share of "Hollywood" moments. The Frogg has wined and dined
such celebritys as actor Kevin McCarthy, actress Joanna
Kerns, Comedians Bill Engvall and Jamie Kaler as well as rock icons
Todd Rundgren and members of the band Live. Tobias S. Frogg
was also featured on an episode of the hit TLC show, "A Baby
Story".
